HBO 'The Idol' cancellation after 1 season draws mixed fan reactions

HBO ‘The Idol’ characterized by its controversial themes and thought-provoking narrative, has been canceled after just one season, leaving fans with divided opinions.

The series was a collaboration between filmmaker Sam Levinson and multi-talented artist Abel ‘The Weeknd’ Tesfaye.

The Idol aimed to shed light on the harsh realities that often accompany stardom. The show explored issues such as substance abuse, exploitation, and the objectification of women.

However, the series’ trajectory took an unexpected turn as it faced cancellation after only one season.

Season 1 was meant to comprise six episodes, but concluded abruptly after five. This left audiences with questions about the creative direction of the series.

HBO’s decision to cancel ‘The Idol’ was reportedly the result of intense deliberations, taking into account both critical reception and viewer feedback.

The news of the show’s cancellation sparked a wave of mixed reactions from fans. Some viewers expressed a sense of relief, arguing that the show’s content was often difficult to stomach (1,2,3,4,5).

The controversial and at times disturbing scenes depicted on-screen, coupled with the portrayal of a misogynistic character played by The Weeknd himself, proved to be off-putting for some audiences.

the idol being canceled is the best news I’ve heard in a while. thank god that misogynistic nightmare was put to an end.
Source

#TheIdol has been cancelled after Season 1. I’m not surprised. It is one of the worst shows I’ve seen this year. The show makes you wanna just throw up and the acting is not proper acting
Source

Conversely, there were those who rallied behind the show, emphasizing its significance in shedding light on the darker aspects of showbiz that are often concealed from the public eye (1,2,3,4,5).

These viewers saw ‘The Idol’ as an unflinching reflection of the highs and lows that celebrities experience and appreciated the show’s willingness to confront uncomfortable truths.

They argue that the cancellation serves as a missed opportunity to continue exploring these crucial themes.

Sucks that they canceled season 2 for the idol. It was getting good and ppl just making big deal didn’t even watch it. Why can’t they just let it be and let fans enjoy the series. And honestly it wasn’t even meant for them.
Source

In a curious twist, some viewers directed their disappointment towards ‘The Weeknd’ himself (1,2). They are attributing the show’s performance to what they perceived as subpar acting on his part.

Some believed that his lack of experience in the acting field impacted the overall quality of the series.

The Weeknd’s character ruined it for me, and the show ruined The Weeknd for me.
Source

Some people are advocating for the release of the original director’s (Amy Seimetz) cut.

These viewers argue that the production process may have lost or altered the intended vision for the series, resulting in its premature cancellation.

They urge HBO to revisit the show and allow its creators to fully realize their initial vision.

Now that the Idol has been cancelled… Can they reboot the show with the original director? And not weeknd of Sam levinson please!!
Source

In the end, ‘The Idol’ will be remembered not only for its provocative content, but also for the intense debates it sparked among viewers.

The cancellation of the series after just one season will likely remain a topic of conversation for some time.

What are your thoughts on the matter? Let us know in the comments down below.

Note: There are more such stories in our dedicated HBO Section so be sure to follow them as well.

Featured image source: The Idol.

PiunikaWeb started as purely an investigative tech journalism website with main focus on ‘breaking’ or ‘exclusive’ news. In no time, our stories got picked up by the likes of Forbes, Foxnews, Gizmodo, TechCrunch, Engadget, The Verge, Macrumors, and many others. Want to know more about us? Head here.